Salmon and the Salmonoid Family on the Fly — Part 2 of 3 · Part 1: Tad Murdoch · Part 3: Mark Kurlansky
David Hartlin hooked his first Atlantic salmon at eight years old, and by his own description, he's never fully recovered. "I've never done any hard drugs," he says, "but from what I've watched on TV, hooking that first Atlantic salmon was just like dabbing a needle in my arm." Salmon anglers call themselves junkies for a reason, and after guiding full-time on Newfoundland's west coast for decades, Hartlin is about as far gone as they come.
The technique he reaches for once the water warms is one of the oldest tricks in Atlantic salmon fishing, and it was invented entirely by accident — by anglers who couldn't afford to replace a broken fly. It's called the Portland hitch, and it turns a sunk wet fly into a fly that wakes across the surface, triggering some of the most explosive takes in freshwater fishing.
What This Technique Is (and What Problem It Solves)
The Portland hitch gets its name from Portland Creek, on Newfoundland's northern peninsula. Generations ago, merchant mariners trading between England and Newfoundland brought over the classic Atlantic salmon wet flies of the day — ornate patterns tied with a gut eye instead of a modern metal one. Local anglers on rivers like Portland Creek didn't have access to replacement flies, and when a fly's gut eye finally rotted and broke, they couldn't just tie on a new one. Being resourceful, they started tying a half-hitch or two directly behind the fly's head and cinching it down on the material to hold the fly on the line without an eye at all.
What they discovered by accident solved a problem nobody was trying to solve: the hitch pulls the fly's nose up and out of the water, so instead of swimming sunk and sleepy, the fly skates and wakes across the surface on the swing. Atlantic salmon holding in smooth, glassy water — fish that might ignore a fly swimming past below them — will come up and smash a fly they can see fleeing across the surface. The hitch turns a presentation problem (how do you get a lethargic, non-feeding fish to react) into a predator-response problem (something is clearly trying to get away), and that's a much easier problem to solve.
Step-by-Step Mechanics
- Tie the hitchBehind the head of the fly, tie one or two simple half-hitches and cinch them down snug on the material. Done correctly, the fly's nose points slightly up and out of the water instead of hanging straight back.
- Pick hitch waterLook for smooth, glassy currents with steady, moderate flow — broken or choppy water won't let the fly hold a visible wake. This is classic "hitch pool" water, the kind locals already know by name.
- Cast across and slightly downstreamA standard wet-fly swing angle works. Let the current do the work rather than stripping the fly.
- Watch the wake, not just the waterAs the fly swings, it should carve a clean V-wake across the surface. That wake is the whole point — it's what triggers the strike.
- Let the take developTakes on a hitched fly are explosive and happen right on the surface. Resist the instinct to set the hook the instant you see it — give the fish a beat to turn down with the fly before you come tight.
- Match fly size to water temperatureEarly in the season, when water is still cold, fish small, sparse wet flies — think size 8 to 10 on a black iron hook — fished more conventionally, sunk. Once the water warms toward the high 50s, switch to the hitch and let the presentation do the triggering instead of the fly itself.
Reading Conditions & Adjusting
Salmon fresh in from a cold ocean are still lethargic. Fish small, sparse wet flies deep and slow instead of hitching — they're not ready to chase anything on the surface yet.
Once temperatures climb toward 58-59°F, salmon noticeably wake up. This is the signal to switch from a sunk presentation to the hitch.
The hitch lives or dies on current quality. A clean, steady flow lets the fly hold a visible wake; broken or riffled water won't show it off the same way.
Salmon hold tighter and warier under bright skies. Push your hitch fishing toward the last hour of fading light — on nearly every fishery, the final stretch before dark consistently outproduces the middle of the day.
Bigger fish are often already in the river when the season opens, frequently in higher water. Fish deeper, heavier wet flies rather than reaching for the surface hitch until flows and temperatures settle into a more typical range.
Common Mistakes
The visual of a salmon crashing a waking fly is enough to make anyone strike early out of pure adrenaline.
FixLet the fish turn down with the fly and load the rod before you come tight. An early strike pulls the fly away from a fish that hasn't actually eaten it yet.
It's a widespread habit, and it's not done out of carelessness — most anglers simply haven't been shown the alternative.
FixSkip the glove. Current research says it does more harm than the grip problem it's meant to solve — tail the fish bare-handed, briefly, or use a proper rubber-mesh landing net instead.
Nobody wants to lose a fish, so the instinct is to play it slowly and carefully.
FixIn good water and conditions, a reasonable rule of thumb is roughly a pound of fish per minute of fight — a five-pound grilse should be released inside four or five minutes, not dragged out for fifteen.
A fly box built for warm-water hitch fishing doesn't serve you in cold, early-season water, and vice versa.
FixMatch fly size and presentation to water temperature — small and sunk when it's cold, hitched and waking once it warms.
It's tempting to stay put on a familiar pool even once it's gone quiet.
FixOn a river system with multiple runs, treat a quiet pool as a cue to move, not a reason to dig in — different rivers and pools on the same system often turn on and off on staggered schedules.
Author's Story & Key Insights
What stuck with me most from talking with Dave wasn't the hitch itself — it was how he talks about the last hour of daylight. He's watched client after client call it quits right as the mosquitoes get bad, head back for a drink, and miss the exact window every guide on that river already knows is the best one. It's such a simple, almost boring piece of advice, and it's also probably the single most repeatable edge in this whole sport: whatever fishery you're on, the last few minutes of legal light are disproportionately when it happens. Dave's seen it enough times on Newfoundland's west coast that he builds his entire daily schedule around it, and it's worth stealing for literally any water you fish.
EP 118 — David Hartlin Guiding
David Hartlin joins the Fly Fishing Insider Podcast to talk Atlantic salmon obsession, the Portland hitch, and guiding Newfoundland's west coast — originally released May 11, 2021.
If you only get one window on hitch water, don't spend it in the first hour after you rig up — save it for the last hour of light. Dave's rule holds up on rivers a long way from Newfoundland, too.
Terms You'll Hear
- Portland Hitch
- A half-hitch tied behind a fly's head that lifts its nose and makes it skate across the surface; it originated on Newfoundland's Portland Creek.
- Grilse
- A young Atlantic salmon that spent only one winter at sea before returning to spawn, typically smaller than a multi-sea-winter fish.
- Leaper
- Atlantic salmon's nickname, earned for the repeated jumps a hooked fish makes.
- Tailing
- Landing a salmon by hand-gripping it just ahead of the tail fin rather than netting or gaffing it.
- Wet-Fly Swing
- The classic downstream-and-across presentation where a sunk fly swings through the current under tension from the line.
- Beat
- A defined stretch of river an angler fishes for a set period — a term rooted in the UK and European Atlantic salmon tradition.
Recommended Fly Patterns
Recommended Gear
Part 1 — The Mindset It Takes to Chase Every Salmonoid Species on Earth (Tad Murdoch)
Part 2 — How to Fish the Portland Hitch for Atlantic Salmon (David Hartlin)
Tight lines, everyone!
If a Portland-hitch take on smooth Newfoundland water sounds like something you need to feel for yourself, David Hartlin guides exactly that fishery on the west coast of Newfoundland.
Book with David Hartlin Guiding